Why My Promotion Made Me Want to Quit

Ron Macklin and Deb Dendy

Why My Promotion Made Me Want to Quit

A dry promotion is when an employee receives a new role or title, along with greater responsibility, but no increase in compensation. While it might seem like a practical, short-term business move, Deb and Ron highlight how this approach clashes with core principles of leadership development and damages trust within organizations.

The Personal Cost: A Leadership Development Opportunity Missed

Ron shares a candid story from early in his career, when he was repeatedly dry promoted into leadership roles. Despite leading projects and delivering results, he remained the lowest-paid team member. This lack of recognition not only impacted his confidence but also sent a damaging message about how the organization valued his contributions—something that often happens in environments lacking strong leadership training programs.

His experience reveals the hidden toll these decisions take on promising employees and on developing company culture rooted in fairness, accountability, and genuine recognition.

Why This Matters for Leadership and Company Culture

Deb and Ron use this real-world example to offer guidance for business leaders looking to create healthier, more effective workplaces:

  • Fair Compensation: Pay should align with the value employees provide—not their age or tenure. Strong leadership development practices demand that organizations reward people based on impact and responsibility.
  • Trust and Retention: Once broken, trust is difficult to rebuild. Dry promotions signal a lack of respect, which can erode team cohesion and transform company culture in the wrong direction.
  • The True Cost of Turnover: Undervaluing employees may seem like a cost-saving measure, but the long-term expense of replacing top talent often outweighs any temporary savings.

Building a Culture That Retains and Grows Talent

The episode highlights how leadership training programs should prepare managers to foster environments where employees feel seen, heard, and rewarded. Companies that invest in people—not just with responsibility but with genuine recognition—are more likely to build sustainable, high-performance cultures.

To create a healthy and thriving company culture, businesses should:

A Call to Action for Business Leaders

Ron and Deb challenge listeners—especially those in leadership—to reflect on their own practices: Would you accept more responsibility without more pay? If not, why should your employees?

Avoid the trap of dry promotions. Instead, build a workplace where people are rewarded fairly, trust is nurtured, and transforming company culture isn’t just a goal—it’s a lived experience.

Episode Summary

Why My Promotion Made Me Want to Quit

Ron and Deb take a closer look at a practice that undermines both leadership credibility and workplace morale: dry promotions. These promotions, where employees are given new titles and increased responsibilities without a pay raise, are more common than many leaders realize—and they carry long-term consequences for company culture and employee engagement.