Why Most Leadership Training Fails – And What Top Leaders Do Instead

Ron Macklin & Deb Dendy

Why Most Leadership Training Fails – And What Top Leaders Do Instead

Reflecting on traditional leadership training courses – especially the standard two-day sessions – raises critical concerns. Can such a condensed timeframe truly foster lasting leadership development? Or does it risk weakening company culture and reinforcing communication problems across teams? In this episode, Ron and Deb explore these questions and reveal the consequences of quick-fix training models.

The Fallacy of Quick Fixes in Leadership Development

Ron and Deb start with a bold claim: short-term leadership training courses might actually harm an organization more than help it. The core issue lies in the false belief that leadership skills can be mastered quickly. Participants often walk away feeling as though they've completed their development journey – when in reality, meaningful growth requires time, practice, and ongoing executive coaching to embed those skills in daily leadership.

Participation vs. Engagement: Addressing Communication Problems

One major issue with traditional training is forced participation. When employees are simply mandated to attend, genuine engagement suffers. Ron notes that in many cases, about half of the participants are mentally checked out – focused more on their existing workload than the training in front of them. This disconnect leads to persistent communication problems and limits the effectiveness of any leadership development efforts.

Leadership Starts at the Top – And Requires Follow-Through

Even when individuals are motivated, they often face a disheartening reality: their senior leaders don’t model the behavior being taught. This hypocrisy can erode trust and reinforce a toxic company culture. Ron and Deb emphasize that real leadership development begins at the top – with executives who not only support training but actively live out the principles themselves.

The Culture Behind Effective Leadership Training Courses

How a company implements leadership training says a lot about its core values. If courses are seen as a box-checking exercise, the outcome will reflect that superficial mindset. A healthy company culture, on the other hand, supports deep, consistent development by investing in tools like executive coaching, feedback systems, and ongoing leadership support.

Building a Culture of Care to Support Growth

To overcome the shortcomings of short-form training, Ron and Deb advocate for building a culture of care. Leaders who genuinely care about their teams create the foundation for more authentic, human-centered leadership. This approach not only strengthens communication but also inspires trust and collaboration – two cornerstones of successful leadership development.

Rethinking Leadership Development as a Journey

Effective leadership can’t be packed into a rigid two-day format. It demands continual effort, real-world experience, and thoughtful reflection. Organizations that prioritize long-term leadership development – through executive coaching, improved communication, and a strong company culture – are the ones best positioned for sustainable growth and innovation.

As Ron and Deb reflect, leadership isn’t about checking boxes. It’s about showing up consistently – with care, courage, and a willingness to grow alongside your team.

Episode Summary

Why Most Leadership Training Fails – And What Top Leaders Do Instead

Ron Macklin and Deb Dendy demystify the adverse effects of mandatory two-day leadership courses. They explore why believing you can learn leadership in such a short time is damaging to both individuals and organizations. Through discussing real scenarios, they highlight the disengagement and frustration these courses can cause, especially when leaders who mandate them do not participate themselves.