Is Your Leadership Fueling Toxic Business Culture? (Five Warning Signs)

Every leader wants a high-performing culture. But sometimes, the very behaviors that drive performance can quietly destroy the foundation of trust that holds a business together.

Toxic culture doesn’t start with bad people — it starts with good intentions gone unchecked. Subtle habits like rewarding the wrong metrics, avoiding difficult conversations, or celebrating the loudest voices can turn collaboration into quiet competition.

Here are five warning signs your leadership might be feeding the very culture you’re trying to fix — and how to turn it around.

1. You Celebrate the Loudest Wins

When recognition goes only to the most visible people or projects, others start playing small. They protect their ideas, stay silent in meetings, and stop experimenting. Over time, the team’s energy shifts from contribution to self-preservation.

Try this instead: Celebrate curiosity and learning as much as results. When people see that growth gets noticed, they start sharing again.

2. You Compare Instead of Connect

Stack-ranking teams or individuals can look like accountability, but it often breeds resentment. People start competing for approval instead of aligning around purpose.

Try this instead: Replace comparison with curiosity. Ask, “What did we learn?” instead of “Who did it best?” Curiosity builds trust; comparison erodes it.

3. You Reward Results Without Seeing the Cost

When success is measured only by outcomes, fear fills the gap. People hide mistakes, skip reflection, and burn out trying to meet the next target.

Try this instead: Recognize the process behind results. Teams that feel safe to fail are the ones who keep innovating.

4. You Avoid Talking About Fear

Fear is always in the room — fear of failure, rejection, or being replaced. When leaders pretend it isn’t there, that silence becomes part of the culture.

Try this instead: Name the fear. Talking about it doesn’t make you weak — it makes you trustworthy. Once fear is visible, it can be redirected into focus and creativity.

5. You Tell the Wrong Story About Success

When success means “winning over others,” people stop helping each other succeed. Silos form, collaboration dies, and creative/skilled people quietly leave.

Try this instead: Tell a new story — one where success looks like growth, connection, and shared wins. Culture changes the moment your story does.

Turning Culture From Toxic to Transformative

A toxic business culture doesn’t appear overnight. It’s built one unspoken rule, one avoided conversation, one unexamined story at a time.
The good news? It can be rebuilt the same way — through small acts of awareness, courage, and belief.

When leaders transform their stories, they transform their culture. And when culture changes, results follow.

Go deeper: Listen to this week’s episode of The Story in Your Head:
🎧 The Hidden Battle Inside Your Business: How Internal Competition Is Destroying Company Culture

‍